Why Do Mechanical Seals Leak? 8 Common Causes and Fixes

Mechanical seal ring with a liquid drop falling from it and the title “Why Do Mechanical Seals Leak?”

A small puddle under the pump, a wet ring around the shaft, or the maintenance team saying “the seal again.” Anyone who works in the field knows this scene. The good news is that mechanical seals rarely fail at random. Behind a leak there are usually a few familiar causes, and most of them can be spotted in advance.

In this article we go through the eight most common causes of leakage, what to look at for each one, and how to prevent it. If you want a refresher on what a mechanical seal is, start with our What Is a Mechanical Seal? article.

First, a distinction: not every trace of moisture is a failure

A very thin fluid film sits between the seal faces, and that film is part of how the seal works. A tiny amount of moisture, often evaporating on its own, can therefore be normal. What should raise an alarm is continuous dripping, a puddle, or wetness that grows over time.

1. Dry running

This is the most common cause and the one that does damage fastest. When a pump runs without enough liquid, the film that cools and lubricates the seal faces disappears. Heat builds up quickly, the faces can crack and the elastomers can burn. According to some sources, damage can start within about half a minute.

Common reasons: A falling liquid level in the tank, a blockage in the suction line, running against a closed valve.
What to do: Add level and flow monitoring, make sure the pump is full before start-up, and use a suitable flush line.

2. Incorrect installation

Even an excellent seal will leak soon if it is fitted wrongly. Uneven tightening of the gland bolts, skipped setting dimensions and ignoring the manufacturer’s instructions are the usual culprits.

What to do: Install according to the instructions and use trained people. Cartridge seals come pre-set from the factory, which noticeably reduces this risk.

3. Shaft misalignment

If the shaft is off its axis, the seal faces are loaded unevenly. The thin film between them breaks down, and friction and local heat increase.

What to do: Check alignment after installation and after maintenance, and make sure pipe strain is not loading the pump.

4. Excessive vibration

The source of vibration is often not the seal. Worn bearings, cavitation or an alignment problem shake the pump, and the seal suffers along with it. The faces separate and the thin film cannot hold.

What to do: Find the source of the vibration first. Replacing the seal without fixing the root cause is not a lasting solution.

5. Solid particles and contamination

Sand, crystallized product, rust or dust that gets between the faces acts like sandpaper. It scratches the faces and opens a leak path.

What to do: Monitor fluid quality and use a filter and flush system. For abrasive products, a double seal with a buffer fluid system is a safer solution.

6. Chemical incompatibility

If the face material or elastomer cannot withstand the fluid, it swells, hardens, cracks or dissolves. From the outside it looks like “the seal failed,” but the real problem is the original material choice.

What to do: Define the fluid type, concentration and temperature clearly. Choose the face material (carbon graphite, silicon carbide, tungsten carbide) and the elastomer (NBR, EPDM, FKM, PTFE) accordingly.

7. Thermal shock and sudden temperature changes

Feeding a cold system suddenly with hot liquid, or the other way around, can crack the faces.

What to do: Start up and shut down in gradual steps, and make sure the cooling and flush lines are working.

8. Wrong selection and operating outside design conditions

A seal is chosen for a specific pressure, temperature, speed and fluid. If the process changes over time but the seal stays the same, trouble is inevitable. Lack of maintenance and incorrect start-up belong in the same group.

What to do: Re-evaluate the seal whenever process conditions change. When you are unsure, ask a specialist instead of guessing.

First checklist when you see a leak

  1. Stop the pump safely and check for liquid and pressure hazards.
  2. Check the tank level and the suction line.
  3. Confirm that the flush and cooling lines are open.
  4. Look for vibration, unusual noise and a rise in temperature.
  5. If the seal has been removed, inspect the faces. Discoloration, cracks or scratches are clues.

Write these observations down. The answer to “when and under what conditions did it start leaking?” is the shortest path to the right solution.

How to prevent leaks from the start

  • Regular checks: Monitor leakage, temperature and vibration as a routine.
  • Early-warning tools: Thermal imaging and vibration analysis can reveal a problem before the seal fails.
  • Clean fluid: Protect the faces with filters and a flush system.
  • Standardization: Using the same seal types on similar pumps simplifies stock and training.
  • The right product: Choosing correctly at the start is the cheapest solution later.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal for a mechanical seal to leak a little?
Because of the thin film between the faces, a very small amount of moisture, often evaporating, can be normal. Continuous dripping or growing wetness is not normal.

Should a leaking seal be repaired or replaced?
It depends on the extent of the damage. If the faces are scratched or cracked, or the elastomers have hardened, fitting a new seal is usually necessary.

What if the seal keeps failing?
Look for the cause before replacing it: check dry running, vibration, alignment and fluid compatibility. If the cause remains, the new seal will fail in the same way.

If your seal keeps leaking, let’s find the cause together.

Send us the pump type, fluid, pressure and temperature, and we will recommend a suitable solution. Phone: +90 212 549 73 25, email: support@rotaseal.com. Browse our mechanical seals, cartridge seals and buffer fluid systems. For fluid transfer into rotating systems, see our What Is a Rotary Joint? article.

Rotaseal Engineering Team

The Rotaseal Engineering Team shares its technical knowledge and engineering expertise in mechanical seals, rotary joints, and industrial sealing solutions. Through our articles, we aim to provide technical insights into industrial applications and support industry professionals in developing reliable solutions.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top